The Road to the Marriage Equality Act of 2015 was anything but easy.
As we are keen to reflect on at EPIC The Irish Emigration Museum, people leave the island for all kinds of reasons – better work opportunities, economic stability, improved quality of life. In the case of our ancestors it was often the only option, whether it was to flee the Famine, or being forced out due to the penal laws.
The pattern of leaving continued; while some areas of Irish life got better, others needed improvement. It’s hard to imagine now, but some even left Ireland in pursuit of love. Homosexuality wasn’t decriminalised until 1993 and gay marriage wasn’t allowed until 2015. One such couple that did this was Dr Katherine Zappone and Dr Ann Louise Gilligan.
In the 1980s, an Irish woman and an American woman met in Boston, fell in love, and despite moving back to Ireland, had to leave again in order to travel to one of the very few places they could legally marry. Even coming up to the 10 year anniversary of the Marriage Equality Act in Ireland, it’s hard to believe this is a right we’ve only allowed for a decade now.
A Historic Vote for Equality
On May 22nd, 2015, the Irish public came out in their droves to their local polling stations. With a 62% majority, they voted to pass Marriage Equality Act in the Republic of Ireland. While other countries had by this point legalised gay marriage, Ireland became the first to do so by popular vote, via a referendum. It was a momentous occasion for a country that only 22 years prior still had it so homosexuality was an illegal offence, which perhaps more than anything sheds a light on how difficult it was to arrive at this historic day.
View this post on Instagram
RTÉ circles back to one couple as being hugely pivotal on the road to Marriage Equality in Ireland – Dr Katherine Zappone and Dr Ann Louise Gilligan. Their incredible story and fight for the equal rights of their heterosexual counterparts raised public awareness about the inequality gap that existed at the time.
A Transatlantic Love Story
The pair met at Boston College in 1981, where they were both pursuing doctorates in theology. Ann was from Dublin, while Katherine hailed from Seattle – the couple quickly fell for one another, embarking on a life-partnership ceremony a year after meeting, according to Herstory, before moving to Ireland in 1983. Katherine officially became an Irish citizen in 1995.
View this post on Instagram
Despite homosexuality being illegal when the women first moved there, they were able to live together quite happily, dedicating themselves to quiet activism, particularly where education was concerned.
The Road to Marriage
Ann and Katherine had been life-partners for almost two decades when a trip to South America in 2001 forced them to update their wills. Although by now it was no longer illegal to be gay, being life-partners was not enough to avail of the same rights afforded to heterosexual married couples, particularly where taxes were concerned. Herstory reports that, “they could not will half of their property to the other upon death, without major capital acquisition taxation implications”.
The couple decided to get married in one of the few places they could across the world in 2003. While Canada as a whole did not recognise gay marriage, the province of Ontario and Vancouver did, the latter of which is where the pair would become legally wed. Despite this, Still, Ireland still did not recognise them as a married couple. According to RTÉ when they applied for the same financial allowances of heterosexual couples, the Revenue Commissioners refused, on the grounds that this specific taxation legislation was only on the basis of a marriage between a man and a woman, not marriage as a whole.
The Marriage Equality Act
This hurdle did not deter Ann and Katherine. They challenged the Revenue Commission’s decision through judicial review. The KAL Advocacy Initiative case was born and went to the High Court in 2006. Unfortunately Ann and Katherine lost their case against the Revenue Commissioners in December. However, all hope was not lost. Publicity around the case made it so KAL became Marriage Equality, a non-profit organisation with the sole goal of ensuring that same-sex relationships could avail of civil marriage, and all the benefits that come with it.
Just under a decade later, that’s exactly what happened. The Marriage Equality act was voted in on May 22nd, and officially came into effect on November 16th. Finally, Ann and Katherine’s marriage was legal in Ireland, and afforded them the same allowances. The following year, Katherine would be appointed Minister for Children and Youth Affairs, the first openly gay woman to be a government minister. She would hold this position for 4 years.
View this post on Instagram
Sadly Ann passed away in June 2017 after a short illness; she was 71 years old.
According to The Irish Times, Executive director of The Irish Council for Civil Liberties Liam Herrick said this of her and Katherine’s joint legacy:
“Ireland owes an immense debt to Ann Louise Gilligan and Katherine Zappone for the more equal society we now enjoy.”
A Lasting Legacy
Dr Katherine Zappone and Dr Ann Louise Gilligan perhaps didn’t realise what they were setting in motion in 2003. Then, they simply wanted to have their marriage recognised, and gain the same rights afforded to other married couples. Though it took many years, the overwhelming majority vote in Ireland made it so their efforts were not in vain. The Marriage Equality Act of 2015 passed with flying colours. Our entire society thanks them immensely for having their story told so we could have a more equal society today.
EPIC covers the Marriage Equality referendum in our Influencer Gallery and Leading Change Gallery. Get your tickets to learn about this important chapter of recent Irish history here.
Other Stories You May Like
The Irish Passport Officially Ranked the Strongest in the World
House of Guinness: The true story of the Guinness family behind the Netflix drama